COMPARISON OF PRE-SCHOOL EDUCATION:
MONTESSORI |
TRADITIONAL |
||
1. |
Child chooses materials. |
1. |
Teacher sets curriculum. |
2. |
Child sets own pace. |
2. |
Teacher sets pace. |
3. |
Child is free to discover on his own. |
3. |
Teacher instructs child. |
4. |
Emphasis on the concrete. |
4. |
Emphasis on the abstract. |
5. |
Specific placement of materials helps refine child’s natural sense of order. |
5. |
Random placement of materials hinders development of this sense of order. |
6. |
Child centred learning environment. |
6. |
Curriculum centred environment. |
7. |
Child provides own stimulus to learning. |
7. |
Teacher provides stimuli to learning. |
8. |
Self-education through self correcting materials. |
8. |
Teacher is the main control of error |
9. |
Recognition of the child’s sensitive periods. |
9. |
All children treated alike and sensitive periods not fully recognised. |
10. |
Multi-sensory materials to develop specific skills. |
10. |
Play materials for non-specific skills. |
11. |
Liberty to move freely, and sit where they please. |
11. |
Rigid rules not to move and to sit in designated places. |
12. |
Liberty to speak (quietly so as not to disturb others). A quiet, calm atmosphere naturally prevails. |
12. |
Silence on many occasions has to be forced in order to control chaos. |
13. |
Directress guides child to think for himself and make sound decisions. Responsibility for decisions made is encouraged. |
13. |
Children not thought of as capable of making decisions and are expected to follow teacher unquestioningly. |
14. |
Disorderly conduct in class is regarded as the directress’ fault; she seeks it out and corrects it. |
14. |
Children are punished for disorderly behaviour even if the fault lies with the teacher’s incapabilities. |
OBJECTIVES IN A MONTESSORI CLASSROOM
To support and encourage each child to:
- Discover the joy of learning through work.
- Become creative, independent learners.
- Experience, explore and experiment with the world around them.
- Create and express themselves freely.
- Acquire good concentration span and good working habits.
- Become clean, neat, tidy and orderly.
- Develop a positive self-image with good self-esteem and confidence.
- Develop a sense of community and responsibility.
- Become aware of special strengths, abilities and uniqueness.
- Be courteous to and respectful of others.
- Learn to care for equipment and share with others.
- Be independent thinkers and self-reliant.

